What would you change about The Lord of the Rings or The Hobbit if given a chance?

As a devoted fan and author of the Hobbit Central site, this question is indeed intriguing. Both The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit are masterpieces that have captivated readers and viewers alike. However, if given an opportunity to make changes, there are a few areas where I believe improvements could be made.

🎭 Unmasking Our Heroes: A Closer Look at Character Growth

One of the first areas I'd focus on is character development. In the Hobbit, the band of dwarves accompanying Bilbo is quite large, and while some characters like Thorin Oakenshield are well fleshed out, others fade into the background. I would delve deeper into the individual stories and personalities of these dwarves, much like my previous hobbit characters analysis.

To get a better understanding of the dwarves' individual stories and personalities, let's take a look at this comprehensive video detailing the full story of the 13 dwarves of Thorin's company.

After watching this video, it's clear that there's a rich tapestry of history and character development that could have been explored more deeply in the films. Similarly, in The Lord of the Rings, some characters could benefit from more screen time or exploration of their backstories.

Similarly, in The Lord of the Rings, some characters could benefit from more screen time or exploration of their backstory. For instance, the elf Legolas and the dwarf Gimli develop a deep friendship that's mostly shown through humorous banter. Providing more moments showcasing the evolution of their bond would enrich the narrative.

🎞️ The Art of Storytelling: Pace and Structure in Middle Earth

Pacing and structure are other elements I would consider adjusting, especially in the Hobbit trilogy. The decision to expand the relatively short children's book into a three-part movie series resulted in some pacing issues. A more balanced distribution of the plot across the films could improve the narrative flow, ensuring the story is neither rushed nor drawn out.

Learn more about Test Your Knowledge: The Hobbit Trilogy Quiz 🧙‍♂️ or discover other Hobbit Central quizzes.

As for The Lord of the Rings, while the extended editions provide a more comprehensive view of the story, they might be overwhelming for new viewers. Offering a guide for first-time watchers indicating crucial scenes and optional ones could be beneficial.

🔍 Riddles in the Dark: Unraveling the Enigmas of The Hobbit

Finally, one of the most charming aspects of The Hobbit is the riddles Bilbo and Gollum exchange in the dark. In my opinion, incorporating more of these riddles and their solutions would add another layer of intrigue and engagement for the audience.

Let's delve deeper into the riddles that add a unique charm to The Hobbit. Here are some frequently asked questions about them:

As we can see, the riddles in The Hobbit are not just puzzles, but pivotal plot elements that contribute to character development and audience engagement. Now, let's move on to the conclusion of our discussion.

In conclusion, while both The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit are remarkable in their current form, these changes could potentially enhance character development, improve pacing, and add another layer of engagement through riddles. Yet, as a devoted fan, I deeply appreciate these stories just as they are, understanding that every narrative has its unique charm and individuality.

Alycia Spencer

Hobbit cuisine, Hobbit meal times, Personal experiences

Alycia Spencer is an accomplished writer with a profound admiration for the culinary traditions of Hobbit culture. She relishes in delving into their distinct meal times and the variety of dishes each one entails. Alycia's articles are a captivating mix of well-researched facts and her personal encounters.